Is Selling on Amazon a Scam? The Full Truth
This is a question I get constantly. And I'm going to answer it honestly — including the parts that make me uncomfortable to say.
The Short Answer
Selling on Amazon is not a scam.
Amazon automation companies that charged people $3,000–$50,000 to "build a passive income store" while doing nothing themselves? Those were scams. And they're the reason the phrase "selling on Amazon" became associated with fraud in a lot of people's minds.
Here's what actually happened.
How "Amazon is a Scam" Became a Thing
Around 2017–2018, e-commerce exploded in popularity. As Amazon became one of the most visible platforms, a wave of companies formed around a concept called "Amazon automation" — done-for-you stores. Their pitch: pay us, we build you an Amazon business, you do nothing, money rolls in.
Prices ranged from $3,000 to $50,000 per "automated store."
At first, the concept wasn't obviously fraudulent. But these companies had a fundamental problem: they couldn't actually deliver. Their customers weren't making money. They weren't getting results. And they weren't getting refunds either.
When the complaints scaled to a volume that caught the attention of the FTC (Federal Trade Commission), investigations opened. Case after case. The biggest players in the Amazon automation space were shut down and ordered to issue tens of millions of dollars in refunds.
News articles ran with "selling on Amazon is a scam." The headlines were technically wrong — it wasn't Amazon being a scam, it was specific companies running deceptive businesses on top of the Amazon platform. But the distinction got lost, and the reputation damage stuck.
The Business Model Was Never the Problem
Let me be clear about this: Amazon FBA is a legitimate business model. Amazon FBM dropshipping is a legitimate business model.
The issue wasn't the model. The issue was the people running "done-for-you" services that:
Anyone could run a similar scam on top of any platform — real estate, cryptocurrency, Shopify. The platform isn't the scam. The deceptive operators exploiting people's desire for passive income were.
The Real Horror Stories
Outside of the automation scams, there are legitimate horror stories about selling on Amazon — account deactivations, suspended accounts, frozen funds, IP violations.
Those are real. They happen. And I don't think it's fair to pretend they don't.
Here's the honest explanation of why they happen: sellers who focus exclusively on making money and ignore the operating requirements of the platform.
Amazon is the world's most customer-focused company. It dominates 61% of e-commerce because it prioritizes the customer experience above everything else. When you sell on Amazon, you're operating inside their ecosystem. They have rules. Account health metrics. Shipping standards. IP policies.
Sellers who treat Amazon like a money machine and ignore the operating requirements get their accounts suspended. Not because Amazon is arbitrary — because Amazon enforces standards that most failing sellers are actively violating.
The sellers I've worked with who have built sustainable businesses for 2+ years aren't doing anything special. They're following the rules. They're protecting their account health metrics. They're treating it like a real business.
JP has been running his Amazon store for 3 years. Christian for 2.5 years. Ray for 2 years. These aren't flukes — they're the outcome of operating correctly.
Red Flags to Watch For
Not everything in this space is legitimate. Here's what should make you run:
"Done for you" / fully automated: If someone tells you they'll build you a passive income store you don't have to manage, be extremely skeptical. That's exactly the pitch that got thousands of people scammed.
Outrageous income promises: "$100,000 in your first month" is not a realistic expectation. Anyone setting that expectation is either lying or setting you up for disappointment. Realistic first-month outcomes are $0–$2,000 for most new sellers.
No evidence of actual results: If someone can't show you the back end of their own store, real student results with documentation, and a track record over multiple years — be cautious.
One-size-fits-all pitches: If the program doesn't adapt to your specific situation — your time, capital, marketplace, product categories — it's likely a template they're selling to everyone without any actual consideration for your success.
What Legitimate Amazon Education Looks Like
I'll tell you directly what I do differently — because transparency is the only way to build trust in this space.
Realistic expectations: If someone comes to me expecting $100,000 in their first month, I tell them the program isn't for them. I won't take their money with that expectation. That's not marketing — it's how I avoid creating the horror stories I just described.
Documented results: Every student result I share comes with real documentation — Seller Central screenshots, actual sales numbers, real video testimonials. Not stock photos and invented names.
It's your business: You control your store. Your bank account. I'm there alongside you, not running things for you. The skills transfer. The knowledge stays with you.
Long-term focus: I don't measure success by how many people start — I measure it by how many people build something that sustains. The account health chapter is the second chapter in the program for a reason: you can't scale what you haven't built on a solid foundation.
The Bottom Line
If you've heard "Amazon is a scam" — now you know where that came from and why it persists. It came from a specific type of fraudulent operator that exploited people's trust, not from the platform itself or from the dropshipping model.
The business works. Over 600 people in my program have built real income from it. Some of them have sustained for 2+ years. The results are documented.
The question isn't whether it's a scam. The question is who you decide to work with.
---
If you want the full picture of what the mentorship program looks like — realistic timelines, how it works, what's included — apply below and let's see if we're a fit.
[Apply to the Mentorship Program →]
